Showing posts with label Economics Lesson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Economics Lesson. Show all posts

Sunday, February 7, 2010

Introduction to two-tiered pricing

In response to the question over differences between Wal Mart and Costco, I will introduce a new concept to explain differences in the pricing scheme between a traditional retailer and a discount club. The difference comes from the way prices are set to increase the propensity to consume for customers.

For a traditional retailer, their goal is to price with a difference of the cost and a percentage markup to cover the fixed and variable costs and have a profit. This markup is usually variable and can be none if the firm seeks to engage in loss leading to take out a competitor. Such a phenomenon occurs often with the opening of a new major retailer, since they can spread the losses out over many stores, so the damage to the company overall is negligible compared to the increased market share from removal of competition.

In contrast, a discount club store operates on a different pricing mechanism. By selling near cost, Costco or Sam's Club offers higher savings (known as consumer surplus) compared to the price they would be willing to pay for the same item in a traditional store. As a result, if the discounter only sold at cost, they would go out of business since the profit motive would be removed and they would lose money since the fixed and variable costs would make them lose money. To counteract this reality, the discounter makes up for the difference in consumer surplus by charging a membership fee which creates a small profit and covers the operating costs. As a result, the membership fee is usually tiered to a point where all consumer surplus is removed from all but the highest volume purchasers, so the consumer is not better off shopping the discounter than anywhere else. Naturally, some consumers, such as those with large families gain some consumer surplus, but the pricing including the membership fee precludes most consumers from benefitting economically, so the firm still realizes profit. This type of pricing is known as two-tiered pricing, and is done to ration things for which different classes of consumers have different levels of elasticity.

Thursday, October 8, 2009

A Seedy Business Perhaps?

Browsing through the financial stories today I came across a particularly interesting storyi nvolving the largest US seed manufacturer, Monsanto. The United States DOJ is investigating whether their use of patented seed results in antitrust by having users controlled by the seed supplier. For example, the soybean crop in the United States uses 96% Monsanto seeds, so anyone wishing to produce the crop is pretty much reliant on a single supplier. This is called monopsony.

Monopsony is the same principle as a monopoly, but reflecting a single buyer(IE inelasticity in the supply curve) versus the single seller (inelasticity in the demand curve) of a monopoly. Frequently monopsonies arise from issue where government is the sole buyer, such as a universal healthcare system, research funding, and in analysis of labor markets for welfare economics. One example of a monospony would be the labor market in a small town with one major ocmpany, say a Wal-Mart or a mine, for instance. Since the single employer has no outside competition, since there is no store which can compete with the company becuase there is some economic factor preventing competition, the employer can charge below market wages since they have price-making power. This difference in wage at the the output level of the monopsonist is exploitation, since a free(completely competitive) economy would pay a worker W(higher) while the wage taker pays (W(monopsony). In other words, by controlling the ability to hire in a market, the monopsonist firm get more money out of each worker since they know the worker cannot easily leave the market.

If you want to read through an econometric research paper on the topic which reaches the conclusion that Wal-Mart is a monopsonist in rural areas and in the South, while having reducing monopsony power in areas where they facor labor criticisms and competition on the West Coast and Northeast, here it is courtesy of the University of Connecticut.

Monday, September 28, 2009

Cuba discovers profit

In a move over sixty years too late, the Cuban government has announced plans to allow farmers to cultivate unused land and sell as much as they can produce. The interesting thing is that it took so long and so much denial of history for the Cuban government to realize reducing output for agricultural goods makes them less profitable to sell when coupled with state-mandated price controls at or below costs. The same policies have been tried in Venezuela, the former USSR, and assorted other failed states. In the Soviet Union the agricultural policy killed nearly a million Ukrainians and led to the worst starvation in the history of Europe. Why would anyone continue such failed policies?

Perhaps the mindset from a third-world nation is such that they see that as more and more people are, sometimes forcibly, placed on formerly vacant land that the output will rise even if the price is set near cost. In the short term this might happen, but in the long term a decline happens because the productivity of farming decreases since the lack of a profit motive means that no investment is made to make the land more fertile. Add into this outright fraudulent agrarian scientific work and you end up with an unsustainable agricultural system.

Well what about the United States you ask? WE are on the other end of the spectrum in that this nation subsidizes food production to the point where a crop like corn is used in everything becuase it is so cheap to produce. In the US system of farm subsidies, over production becomes a bigger problem because the subsidies drop down the cost of production to a point below the completely competitive equilibrium, which results in overproduction of some crops and underproduction of others. To see an example of this phenomenon, look at all of the products containing corn bbyproducts. From sodas to batteries to plastics, this single grain exists in every consumer good at some point in the production process. Why? Because it is cheap and the subsidies that already existed for decades were supplemented by further subsidies for ethanol so corn was produced in even larger amounts.

In short, this is a simple economics lesson. Ceteri parabus, the more you subsidize a behavior or item, the more of it you get. The more you tax an item the less of it you get. This is true for most things, however in some instances the societal cost of reducing a tax may outweigh the benefit. These shall be discussed later.

Sunday, August 23, 2009

Does the minimum wage cause unemployment to rise?

I have frequently heard the argument made that increases in the minimum wage should always cause unemployment to rise since it increases the minimum cost of employing a worker. How true it is this statement and what variables affect the validity of the question?

The first two points to be examines are 1) is the state or city raising minimum wage in a situation in which there is a shortage(above equilibrium wage) or surplus(below equilibrium wage) of workers and 2) how many people are affected by the minimum wage increase compared to the total labor market. On the first point, places with a shortage of workers will not see a strain on hiring enforced by minimum wage increases as the market price of labor is already in excess of the minimum wage. This would be the case in a city like New York City where the cost of living makes lower-wage workers scarce because there is nobody willing to work at minimum wage when it is not enough to cover basic goods. On the converse, in a place with a flood of workers compares to employers such as a small town, the wages are below equilibrium so increases in minimum wage will cause unemployment as workers are costing more than the market will bear. The former case is illustrated by the above chart where the equilibrium price for a worker (P*) is above that of the minimum wage (P1). As a result, the quantity of workers desired by businesses(q1) is higher than those who will realistically work at said wages(q2). As a result, and increase in the minimum wage up the equilibrium point will have the effect of actually raising employment levels because some marginal workers will be desiring to work at the higher wages than at the previous minimum wage. Comparisons of employment rates in both low and high minimum wage states shows that there is little difference in employment levels between states which pay the minimum, such as Texas, and states which pay more, such as California and Oregon. The reason has to do with the low number of workers who make the minimum wage in the United States. which is 3% of all hourly workers in the United States. AS a result, the change in minimum wage ends up making 97% of all workers relatively less expensive since they are making less in real terms since the lowest level of compensation rises.

Comparing states with high than Federal minimum wage and those with lower than federal minimum wage on employment levels reveals the following (data taken from the Bureau of Labor Statistics) shows that the thirteen states plus DC which have higher than federal minimum wages average 10.25% unemployment. The nine with lower minimum wages than federal average 8.8% unemployment. While this is a bit higher, it also reflects a difference in the characteristics of the two types of states which deflates the unemployment figures. The higher wage states tended to be more adversely affected by the housing collapse and outsourcing of manufacturing becuase they were more urbanized and industrial states such as MI, CA, RI, OH while the low wage states are Southern states and other states with larger farm populations which are not in the unemployment numbers such as AR, KS, WY, AL, LA, MS. Of the high wage state 43% were below the national unemployment rate and 55.6% of low wage states were below the national unemployment rate. In short, there is a slight increase in unemployment caused by minimum wage on the aggregate level, but it is mostly a function of low wages in a lot of the nation and it is not universally true that unemployment causes increased unemployment in all situations

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

simple economics-supply and demand

Here is the world's simplest supply and demand explanation


Thursday, January 29, 2009

The Law of Unintended Consequences

One of the primary problems in any policy question is how to deal with externalities, the non price costs/benefits of enacting a policy. Some examples include pollution, noise, increased or decreased value, etc. Well while riding my bike I came across a perfect example of an externality and the problem with policy's not truly reflecting the costs versus the benefits.

Here in San Antonio, the city decided last year to stop euthanizing dogs at the pound. This movement was headed up by wealthy women from areas where dogs are strictly regulated such as the posh old money nighborhood of Alamo Heights. So these women, who I will refer to as party A, the benefit of being able to appease their morality is greater than the cost to them, which is close to zero. On the other side of town, in the poor areas of the southwest, citizens who wish to walk or ride their bike encounter feral dogs on a regular basis. For these people, let's call them party B, the benefit to the policy is close to zero and the cost is much higher due to their being no space to put newly found strays in the shelter since the space that would be freed up by euthanization is taken.

Why is it that party A is able to pass a law which helps a very tiny minority of people while hurting most individuals? Simple, the role of money internalizes the cost for the city councilors representing the poor areas. The money from party A offsets the costs in potential lost voters from party B, so the MB>MC so the motion passes. The second reason is that while many poor people are adversely affected by having rabid dogs wandering their neighborhoods, they do not vote to reflect this. Thus the sum of all MB>sum of all MC when it comes to voting.

As a result, poor policy decisions occur which hurt most individuals, but politically make sense. This often leads to the titular law of unintended consequences as the poor decisions spill over into other areas such as the increased number of strays from a no kill policy, increased housing prices due to homeownership programs, and increased health care costs due to insurance.

Saturday, November 29, 2008

Today's Economics Lesson-Why Agriculture is Only Done By Big Corporations With Any Success

Today's lesson is a two-fold lesson encompassing the concepts of economies of scale and the perfectly competitive firm structure. The first concept, economies of scale refers to the ability for larger firms to squeeze out additional units at lower and lower costs as they expand to the greatest marginal return. In other words, since fixed costs are highest at the first unit of output, the additional units spread out these costs over more and more units. This results in lower average cost per unit until diminishing returns set in. Diminishing returns means that for each unit past the minimum average cost level, the increase in marginal cost is greater than the benefit or revenue of the next unit.

For agriculture the fixed costs are quite high because land is thousands of dollars and acre, and the inputs for production such as tractors, feed, corrals, etc. are very expensive. As a result, the smaller farmer has to pay for the capital cost of their operation over a smaller number of units, so their average cost is higher than a corporate farm where the equipment and land costs are spread out of a factor of the smaller guy's operation. In other words, if farmer Joe and farmer Jim both raise cows in the same area, but farmer Joe has only ten acres and farmer Jim as a thousand, then farmer Jim has the ability(if his money allows) to purchase more cows than Joe possibly could, so the cost of the truck, trailer, feed will be spread out over however many units each one's land can produce efficiently.

A second consideration is the type of market structure an agricultural business exisists within. Since product differentiation between most agricultural products is pretty much nonexistent(ie one cannot tell apart milk from Joe's cows compared to milk from Jim's cows) and anyone who can buy land and cows can enter the market, and also that millions of little producers are creating milk at any given time result in a nearly perfectly competitive market. This has two important meanings economically: 1) that the homogenous nature of the product and number of sellers means nobody has the ability to control price or collude, and 2) that in the long run the economic profit is zero because firms can easily enter or exit the market depending on supply and demand conditions. As a result, the spot price for an agricultural good is the price anyone pays for it, so anything above that price will not sell at all. This creates a problem because the producers are reliant on say milk pricing being X, but then they fall and suddenly the smaller firm has the same costs but shrinking revenue. If the price rises, the smaller firm may be able to have a short term profit, but the price will go lower due to new firms producing the formerly profitable good.

Given how economically despairing the idea of being a small farmer is, so many people in this country still attempt it. The downfall of the family farm is an unfortunate side effect of the economic realization of the preceding lesson, in that the wages earned being a small farmer are more work and lower than what could be earned at a service job. If this were not the case, why would whole swathes of the nation see their children flee and towns become vacant as the last generations of farmer pass on?

Wednesday, June 11, 2008

Today's Lesson-Corporate Taxes are Paid by Consumers

While there is little good to be said of Congress lately, they made one intelligent move by having the windfall profits on oil tax filibustered. While I am as pissed as the next guy about paying four dollars a gallon in gas, basic knowledge of how economic systems work will dictate that taxing profits fails to do anythign about the price of oil, in fact it will raise it.

To understand why a tax on the profits beyond the normal corporate tax will be passedo nto consumers, one must understand that in any economy there are two sides. One side, the demand side, is made up of the businesses and households and governments which spending money or taxes to get goods and services. The other side, the supply side, is the producers(businesses) who create the goods and services the consumers want based on this old law called supply and demand. When there are more buyers than sellers, price rises, and when there are more sellers than buyers price falls. When income shrinks, demand falls, yada,yada,yada. To cut the story short, in the total (aggregate) supply of goods in this country there are two factors which have exogenous variables-output and price. When a tax occurs on a corporation, the price of producing a good goes up because the tax is added into the price in order to maintain profit margins. If the tax were not added into the price, the company would be unable to make money as the would soon have costs exceeding revenue from all of the costs of labor, taxes, overhead, etc. By increasing the taxation on oil companies, the cost of each barrel will rise to maintain profit margins, increasing the price of each barrell. At the same time, fewer people will be able to drive because of the increased prices, which lowers demand. This causes the amount of tax revenue from gas taxes to decrease, which leads to infrastructure problems, and so on and so forth.

In conclusion, businesses seek to make profits, otherwise they would be charities. By increasing the cost to produce on a company, the price of each product rises and demand falls. With oil the price of every product rises due to the use in transportation and being a factor in so many different goods. Even if one did not own a car, the cost of the bike tires would go up, as would the helmet, the backpacks, and the water bottle all rise since all are made from petroleum-based plastics and use petroleum biproducts. Enjoy

Sunday, May 4, 2008

First post in ages

While I have been bogged down in economics finals, I decided to post something to break the silence. Today's lesson is the relationship between money supply and output, a concept which was not understood before the 60's and Milton Friedman.

In short, the relationship is governed by a balanced equation where the change in money supply time the velocity(how fast money circulates in an economy) is equal to the change in output time the change in prices. In other words MS*V=Q*P. Thus if the money supply rises, either price or output, or both must rise to match the increase. The effect of this relationship is that inflation and deflation are better understood as products of MS, rather than being arbitrary. Also, if money loses enough value that it ceases to be circulated much, then serious deflation occurs, as happened during the early days of American Banking. The goal of an economy should be to balance these forces out to keep output rising without increasing inflation outside of comfortable levers(circa 3%). For much of the 90's we were in such a pattern, but the collapse of the housing market and the lowering of interest rates to 2% increased prices and a slight amount of output, but since P was greater than Q, real inflation occurred.

Thursday, April 10, 2008

Today's Economic Lesson, Public Vs. Private Goods

From the Road to Serfdom by FA Hayek:


There are, finally, undoubted fields where no legal arrangements can create the main condition on which the usefulness of the system of competition and private property depends: namely, that the owner benefits from all the useful services rendered by his property and suffers for all the damages caused to others by its use. Where, for example, it is impracticable to make the enjoyment of certain services dependent on the payment of a price, competition will not produce the services; and the price system becomes similarly ineffective when the damage caused to others by certain uses of property cannot be effectively charged to the owner of that property. In all these instances there is a divergence between the items which enter into private calculation and those which affect social welfare; and, whenever this divergence becomes important, some method other than competition may have to be found to supply the services in question. Thus neither the provision of signposts on the roads nor, in most circumstances, that of the roads themselves can be paid for by every individual user. Nor can certain harmful effects of deforestation, of some methods of farming, or of the smoke and noise of factories be confined to the owner of the property in question or to those who are willing to submit to the damage for an agreed compensation. In such instances we must find some substitute for the regulation by the price mechanism. But the fact that we have to resort to the substitution of direct regulation by authority where the conditions for the proper working of competition cannot be created does not prove that we should suppress competition where it can be made to function.

Hayek says in this passage that certain goods are not functions of the normal supply and demand functions, so the cost to produce them or the benefits of production do not make economic sense to be produced, yet are necessary to the society. Examples of such things are military defense, as one cannot price the level of defense an individual needs since the state's defense encompasses all who live in it, regardless of their contribution. In other words, marginal benefit(MB) of the first user is the same as the second, is the same as the third, etc. The example in the passage about pollution from logging is an example of an externality(which shall be covered later) but clean air and water are public goods. Some public goods arise out of necessity to life, such as waterm and cannot be very effectively priced. If water were effectively priced based on market conditions, the resulting cost(people dying of dehydration and disrorder) would be far greater than the private benefit (profits for the water provider). In other words in a public good the social benefit(the benefit to society) outweighs the private benefit (benefit to the individual) and the marginal benefits to society are greater than the marginal benefits to the private individual.

Further, a true public good has two key characteristics--non rivalrous and non exclusionary. That means that a public good does not have competition and cannot have the benefit to one individual reduced by enjoyment of another(why MB is the same regardless of the number of consumers). At the opposite end of the spectrum are exclusive and rivalrous good-- private goods-- which result in private benefit being much greater than social benefit. A home is a private good because the enjoyment of the home for the owner is of greater benefit than the marginal benefit of having strangers also inhabit the home, which reduces the benefit for the individual. Most goods are closer to the pure private good end of the spectrum.

Are schools public goods is an often argued question in public policy classes. Here at the Invisible Boot we exam the question based on the characteristics of a public good. Let us go through a list of characteristics to examine.

1)Are public schools nonrivalrous(no substitute)?- No, they have competition from charter schools and private schools

2)Are they non exclusionary- No, the geographic boundaries of schools means that lower income students are excluded from wealthier schools with larger budgets, so the benefit to each user is not equal.

3) Is marginal benefit the same regardless of the number of users- No, the more users a school has, the lower the benefits due to reduced attention to each student a teach gives, and the scale of the school causes inefficiency in allocating resources as the volume of students creates more problems with management relative to the increase in money from each new student.

Wednesday, March 26, 2008

Today's Lesson-Scarcity and Price

In the over consuming society we live, numerous examples of this problem exist. The most basic idea for this comes from the "diamond and water" paradox. It asks why water, the basis for all life on Earth is nearly free, while diamonds for jewelry--which serve no practical function, cost thousands of dollars. Simply, the reason is scarcity, as diamonds exist in smaller quantities and as such the demand is relatively inelastic(closer to a vertical line) while water is more elastic(closer to a horizontal line).



In simple terms, that means that the more diamonds are on the market, the demand is roughly the same so price does not move. Water on the other hand has such a nearly fixed price that creating new methods of obtaining it does not change the price by much. Water cannot ever be free, however, as price acts as a regulator of behavior. At a price of zero, waste is rampant, as occurred during free water projects in Africa in the 1990s.



On the other side, luxury goods have inflated values attached to them which lead to waste in the same manner as freeing a basic good. One result is that the perceived status carries an economic value, resulting in irrational economic decisions. This distortion of real value causes people who purchase luxury goods beyond their means to engage in economically disadvantageous behavior, such as paying high interest credit or fractional ownership, leading to much greater financial pain than simply purchasing the good outright.

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Economics Lesson, Supply and Demand for Money


What does this mean?

It means that the higher interest rates are, the lower the amound of money needed in the market at that time, which results in either the money supply shrinking(deflation) or interest rates(IR falling) to allow borrowing of money at the level the market demands. Conversely, in a situation where the IR is dropped below the efficient level(E), the quantity demanded is greater than the supply of money, so either the money supply increases(inflation) or IR rises to get closer to equilibrium. Guess which one is the current situation and which one was the situation in the 1970s...